Simply astounding.
I don’t know how else to describe this market. The major indices began sliding midday Thursday as each index began breaking beneath their October lows. The selling began to accelerate as stop losses were triggered to avoid larger losses below the October support. The market looked hopeless, ready to lose another 20% in an instant.
But then something happened. Buyers came into this market, making a last stand to prevent another catastrophic decline. In three hours the DOW gained over 800 points (more than 10%), giving the bulls yet another chance to save this market.
Regular readers of this blog know I have begun to shift my focus from away from the broken financials to the energy names. As the market as a whole has traded back to their 52 week lows, I have found it odd that the energy names have resisted the latest decline. I have raised this issue many times recently.
October 23:
One other point to bring up today. If you can, find a 2 week comparison chart of the USO (crude oil) and the XLE (energy ETF). The USO is down 13% in the 10 previous sessions, but the XLE is actually UP 10% during this time. This caught my eye today.
Now…you may recall crude oil ran high from the beginning of June until mid July. But the XLE actually lost about 8% from June to mid July. This signified the top for crude. Could we be seeing the same trade in reverse? Are the energy stocks acting as a leading indicator again, predicting another reversal in crude oil prices? We will probably find out very soon.
October 30:
But the market is beginning to expose some new themes (for lack of a better word). For instance, the energy stocks exploded today despite oil and natural gas getting pounded. Look at how HK performed and then understand that natural gas lost 7%. Gold was also dropped 2%, but most miners performed well. These stocks have been mirroring the actual commodities for month – which have done nothing but fall from the sky. So one must take notice that HK is up 55%(!) in 10 days while natural gas is down 9%.
November 8:
I am seeing some interesting trading among the inverse ETFs. For instance, take a look at the ultra short oil and gas fund, DUG. This security is more than 50% off from it’s recent high. Now look at DIG, the ultra long fund. DIG is barely off its recent low. I find this peculiar. Even though money is still leaving energy (OIH, XLE and USO are still trading in the basement), DUG has crashed back to earth.
November 13:
So what will be the cause that sends the market to new lows? I propose that it all depends on the energy stocks.
The market first rallied off the October lows because of the strong buying in the oil and natural gas stocks. XOM, HK, CVX, XTO and other names soared higher with the rest of the market. Now that the DOW and S&P 500 are back to the October lows, many energy names are still trading anywhere from 10 to 15% higher from their October bottoms.
I find this divergence even more compelling because the price of oil and natural gas continue to reach new depths. In fact, crude oil has lost 32% since last month. Yet, XOM is only down 5%. Somehow, the energy names have held up well of late as energy prices slide (gas is back to $2 a gallon!) But the integrated oil names began selling off during yesterday’s afternoon slide.
Every other sector is back to new lows. The financials are terrible; reports from M and BBY showed retail cannot be owned because the consumer is staying home; heathcare has been rolling over for weeks. If XOM, CVX and COP continue yesterday’s drop the October lows will be taken out.
You may find it interesting to hear that energy stocks were trading much higher Thursday as the market began to slide down 2%. XOM, CVX and others held firm as the major indices traded right on their lows from October. The bears were not able to break the oil stocks, and I believe this saved the market on Thursday.
Friday’s trading similarly erratic. The market traded much lower early on the session. As it has been the case recently, equities began to rally in the afternoon, pushing the DOW into positive territory. Then, in the final hour of trading the DOW lost 400 points.
The market is being whipped around by speculation as to the future of the economy. We are certainly recessing, but how high will unemployment rise?…10%?…15%? Will GM and F be bailed out? Will foreclosure rates continue to rise? How bad will the holiday season shopping be? I tend to think it will be worse than the market is anticipating. For that reason, and the continued decline of asset prices, suggests being bearish is the proper stance to take. And keep your eye on the energy stocks.